"Babies are sensitive creatures and pick up on everything. Birth seems to affect their behaviour both directly and indirectly – they are in tune with their mother’s neurohormonal state, reflecting her mood, but they also respond to how she interacts with them."
Dr. Carmen Power Tweet
In this thought-provoking interview, Dr. Carmen Power shares how her passion for understanding birth, bonding, and baby behaviour was ignited, the critical importance of the first 1001 days of life, and why perinatal mental health is pivotal for families to thrive. She also highlights the urgent need for a preventative approach in maternity care, addressing issues such as trauma, bonding, and stigma around mental health.
Carmen Power is a psychologist, writer, researcher, educator and consultant on the inter-related topics of childbirth, perinatal mental health, parent-infant bonding, and infant behaviour, temperament and development. Previously a trained doula, hypnobirthing practitioner and early-years education specialist, Carmen has a PhD in Public Health exploring mothers’ experiences of childbirth and early infant temperament from both health professional and maternal perspectives. Carmen is involved in many high-profile international collaborations including with the Society for Reproductive and Infant Psychology (SRIP); TREASURE – a multidisciplinary European collaborative examining Maternal Perinatal Stress and Adverse Outcomes in the Offspring: Maximising Infants’ Development; and an ongoing collaboration about Humanising Childbirth with midwifery professors Soo Downe, Jane Sandall and Lesley Page (CBE). Carmen also carries out consultancy work for charities such as the Parent Infant Foundation and Royal Foundation on childbirth, parent-infant bonding and infant social-emotional development. She tutors in Psychology, Education and Public Health, mentoring students from various UK universities, including London, Oxford and Cambridge. Carmen frequently presents her work at international midwifery, reproductive and infant psychology conferences and is an active member of SRIP and the World Association of Infant Mental Health (WAIMH). Her specific area of expertise is around maternal childbirth experiences and infant behavioural outcomes.
Hi Carmen – can you tell us about your work and research in the field of perinatal wellbeing and early infant development? What led you to focus on topics like mother-infant bonding, the impact of childbirth experiences, and early infant behaviour?
Hi Daisy, thanks so much for giving me this opportunity to talk about my work. I’ll begin by explaining my interest in birth, bonding and baby behaviour, which stemmed from my own two birth experiences being so different and my babies behaving so differently, despite having the same parents caring for them in more or less the same way. Although of course we all tend to be a bit more relaxed as parents with our second baby!
I had a really tricky time with the first birth – it turned out she was stuck in occipito posterior position, but the midwife had encouraged me to push against a brick wall for two hours before calling the doctor in. The poor baby eventually came out with forceps and had a massive red mountain of bruising on her head. She screamed all night after she was born. The midwives tried to take her away so we could all ‘get some sleep’, but I chased them up the corridor, hobbling along despite my episiotomy stitches until they reluctantly agreed to come and help settle the baby next to me. My second baby breezed into the birthing pool and smiled within moments of being born, and we just got off to an easier beginning. This got me thinking – was it the birth that had affected my babies, or was it me? Were my babies responding to what physically happened to them or to how the birth had made their mother feel? I wanted to investigate this.
In your experience, what are the most overlooked aspects of perinatal mental health that healthcare professionals should be addressing?
I think we urgently need to prevent perinatal mental health problems from developing rather than putting people on long waiting lists for treatment after they have suffered for months and their relationship with their baby has already been affected. Those early days are so important for parent-infant bonding, and if we could just provide the emotional support and nurturing that mothers and babies so desperately need on maternity and postnatal wards, we might prevent a lot of damage. Bonding and attachment are massively affected by a parent’s distress or negative postnatal mood. When mothers are traumatised by their birth experience, it’s often because they have not been listened to or properly consulted; they’ve felt out of control and disempowered. And as one midwife so aptly put it, how can you bond with a baby that’s caused you so much pain and distress? For any type of birth, parents should be fully informed of all the options – the risks and benefits – and given the opportunity to make informed choices with a known and trusted midwife and their partner, and without any scaremongering, coercion or unconsented interventions taking place, as they so often do. If we did this, I think we’d prevent a lot of postnatal mood disorders, including anxiety, depression and PTSD, that are all now on such a steeply rising trajectory.
What role can midwives, health visitors, and other professionals play in supporting parents experiencing domestic abuse during the perinatal period?
This isn’t really my area of expertise, although a couple of my students wrote their masters dissertations about domestic violence and abuse, including one about the important role teachers can play in helping to break intergenerational cycles of abuse. Protecting the super vulnerable and hyper-sensitive baby is absolutely essential, so observing whether the baby seems settled and relaxed or is ‘living on its nerves’ as one health visitor described it might be a good way to assess whether the baby’s being adversely affected. And then listening to mothers, gaining their trust and being there to support them is vital if they’re ever going to find the strength to protect themselves and their babies from further physical or psychological harm.
In your research, how do maternity care providers perceive the link between childbirth experiences and infant behaviour? What can be done to bridge any gaps in understanding?
Midwives and health visitors constantly observe how the baby responds physiologically to their birth experience and is initially affected by the direct physical impacts of this (e.g. pain after a forceps birth, pain relief medications and maternal stress hormones). But most seem to feel that the mother’s personal and subjective birth experience is even more important as this affects how the mother feels postnatally and influences her feelings and behaviour towards the baby. This of course affects bonding. Several midwives and health visitors also spoke about the way the baby ‘mirrors’ the mother, reflecting her postnatal mood. Therefore, the pathway between childbirth experience and baby behaviour is probably via perinatal mental health, the way this affects the baby directly through the so-called ‘stress contagion’, but also the way it disrupts bonding and the ongoing negative impact that poor bonding has on infant behaviour and development; but we don’t actually know this for sure, so we need more studies on the potential pathway between the mother’s birth experience, perinatal mental health and bonding.
How does the maternal childbirth experience influence an infant’s early behavioural style, and what are the key factors involved?
If the mother has a positive experience, she is more likely to feel good about herself, empowered and confident to care for the baby. After a traumatic birth experience, the opposite is true. Babies are sensitive creatures and pick up on everything. Birth seems to affect their behaviour in both direct and indirect ways – babies are in tune with their mother’s neurohormonal state, reflecting their mother’s mood, but they also respond to the way she interacts with them. If the mother is quiet and withdrawn, according to health visitors, the baby may also shut down. The partner’s role here is especially important – if the partner is not depressed or traumatised by the birth as well, they can bond with the baby while supporting the mother. This baby should then still be able to thrive while the mother recovers from trauma.
Why are the first 1001 days of a child’s life so critical for their development, and how can we better support mothers and families during this period?
The importance of the first 1001 days can’t really be overstated. Whereas we used to think babies and young children were resilient and would simply ‘bounce back’, we now know how deeply affected they are by their very earliest experiences – from their time in the womb to the early postnatal period and beyond. We really need to stop focussing solely on having a ‘live baby’ at all costs – of course, we all absolutely want babies to be born alive, but we also need to care for their parents’ physical and psychological wellbeing during and after childbirth if we want babies to thrive. We can’t simply continue as if this doesn’t matter. Perinatal mental health is critical to long-term physical and mental health outcomes for the baby and to their development in all spheres – physical, social-emotional, communication and language, and cognitive development. Babies can’t grow and develop in the way they should unless we support parents better – especially vulnerable parents (e.g. gender or neurodiverse parents, migrants or refugees). And, while supporting parents, we also need to facilitate the things that are most conducive to positive health outcomes for the baby – skin-to-skin, breastfeeding and bonding. Midwives and health visitors are in an ideal position to do this but aren’t given enough time and space to provide the type of care they want to.
How do shame and stigma surrounding perinatal mental health challenges affect mothers, and what can we do to promote a more supportive environment?
Mental health needs to be on the agenda for every birth. Vulnerable parents need extra physical and emotional support from healthcare professionals. As I discovered when analysing data for the Parent-Infant Foundation’s project Securing Healthy Lives, it can be really difficult for parents to confess when they need help with their mental health, parenting or bonding. They often feel very guilty and ashamed and are terrified of having their baby taken away. Parents need to know that someone cares and will listen, help and advise them without judging. We need to train and fund more health visitors to work with vulnerable families for longer – this could save the NHS a fortune as longer-term mental health care might be avoided. Meanwhile, charities like the Parent-Infant Foundation and For Baby’s Sake fulfil an essential role in helping to plug this gap.
Can you tell us more about your upcoming book? What inspired you to write it, and what do you hope readers will take away from it?
I’m really excited to have nearly finished the first draft of my book about Birth, Bonding and Baby Behaviour. I’m passionate about these topics and how interconnected they are. As I said at the beginning, it was the births of my own children that first inspired me to think about this connection. Then, when I was conducting a survey of 1000 mothers alongside interviewing mothers, midwives, health visitors and doulas for my PhD, although I’d never thought to ask specifically about bonding, what kept coming up was the bonding – how birth affects baby behaviour directly but also indirectly through its impacts on perinatal mental health and bonding. I’m hoping the book will be a useful tool for healthcare professionals who want to know more about parents’ psychological and emotional needs during childbirth, how they can make a difference to positive outcomes for mother and baby, and how best to support the whole family through this important life-changing transition. This includes all families of all diversities – e.g. black, brown, gender- and neurodiverse parents, who may require even more care and attention during the early stages of their birth and parenting journey.
Thank you for sharing, Carmen!
If you’d like to be involved in our Guest Contributor series, please email daisyobrien@forbabyssake.org.uk

